Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Felix Bölter's avatar

Hmm... This post did what I always hope a Substack read will do: It made me think.

But with thinking comes skepticism - and I'm not sure how persuasive the Harry Potter- argument is.

I read or listened to all books of Sanderson's "Stormlight Archive" and "Mistborn" series, Heitz' "Ulldart" and Paolini's "Eragon", to name just a few.

I remember thoroughly enjoying all of them - but I couldn't recall many details of any of these stories if my life depended on it.

I don't know why it's different with Harry Potter - which, I agree, it is -, but I find it plausible to suspect that reading the books and watching the movies as well as playing games around that universe did something close to active recall.

But again, that's just my first skeptical reaction. Regardless of whether or not stories are better teaching methods than some tactical approach, they are more fun for sure; they are also more difficult to write well. Thanks for the input!

Expand full comment
Justin Ross's avatar

Love this.

The biggest thing I've learned from writing is to never use logic where a story will do.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts